Impeachment
Profs. Solum & Manheim
Instructions for Mock Trial and Final Paper
The last 2 class sessions will be a mock Senate Impeachment Trial of President Clinton.
- In session #1 (April 15):
- The House Managers will have 30 minutes to present their case (including up to 10 minutes for rebuttal).
- The President's Counsel will have a like time to argue their case.
- In session #2 (April 22):
- 20 minutes will be allotted for questions from Senators. Each Senator will be allowed (and expected) to ask 1 question directed at either a Manager or Defense Counsel.
- At the conclusion of questioning, each Senator will cast her vote and give an explanation for it (not to exceed 5 minutes each). Prepared statements are allowed.
Final papers will be based on your in-class presentation.
- House Managers and President's Counsel will submit trial briefs arguing, respectively, for and against conviction.
- Senators will submit written opinions sustaining or rejecting the impeachment charges.
- Briefs & opinions should be between 12 and 20 pages long. They should be based on the actual impeachment record and any materials distributed or discussed in this class.
- Students may submit drafts (optional) of their papers at any time before the end of classes (April 26). Students are encouraged to write their drafts before their class presentation.
- Final papers are due the last day of finals (May 15).
Guideline for Papers
- Arguments may and papers should include discussion of
- the facts
- precedent
- standards for impeachment (high crimes & burdens of proof)
- the impeachment process and any irregularities therein
- Papers should be in proper form (brief or opinion) and conform to Harvard Blue Book citation format.
Your final grade is based on your final paper (2/3) and class participation (1/3), which includes your oral participation in the mock impeachment trial.